Articles

The Intentions with Which the Road is Paved: Attitudes to Liberalism as Determinants of Greenwashing

T. ROULET, S. TOUBOUL

Journal of Business Ethics

mai 2015, vol. 128, n°2, pp.305-320

Départements : Stratégie et Politique d’Entreprise

Mots clés : Corporate social actions, Greenwashing, Economic liberalism, Competition, Individual responsibility, Country-level institutions

http://ssrn.com/abstract=2401072


Previous literature has shown contradictory results regarding the relationship between economic liberalism at the country level and firms’ engagement in corporate social action. Because liberalism is associated with individualism, it is often assumed that firms will engage in mostly symbolic rather than substantive social and environmental actions; in other words, they will practice 'greenwashing'. To understand how cultural beliefs in the virtues of liberalism affect the likelihood of greenwashing, we disentangle the effects of the distinct and co-existing beliefs in the virtues of economic liberalism. We begin by conducting an exploratory qualitative analysis of managers’ sentiments on this matter, based on a focus group methodology. We then use these investigative elements to articulate a comparison of the conflicting theoretical arguments: in liberal contexts, are firms, as social entities, inherently selfish or pro-active when it comes to corporate social actions? We empirically test our hypotheses on a large-scale dataset. Finally, we show paradoxically that in countries where beliefs in the virtues of competition are strong, firms are more likely to greenwash, while in countries where beliefs in the virtues of individual responsibility are prominent, firms are more likely to focus on concrete actions. These findings suggest that in contexts where weak governments are seen as ideal, firms might feel the need to step in to fill institutional voids, in contexts in which competitive mindsets dominate, this tendency is counterbalanced


JavaScriptSettings